Low Carb Vs Low Fat Diet

Must Try

Precautions To Take While Dieting

Low-Carb vs Low-Fat Diets for Weight Loss

A lot of people think that losing weight is easy but it’s not. Regardless of how determined you are, there are some things that you should keep in mind while dieting.

Dieting, as much as we hate to admit it, is boring. You aren’t allowed to have all the fun foods that you enjoy and that’s where temptations kick in. You begin to imagine what life would be like if you could eat all the food you wanted. Eating healthy means that you can’t eat any junk food but it also means that you have to cut various habits that you have with food.

Dieting is a lifestyle choice that you are making because you want to improve your health and well-being in the long term. It means youre changing your eating habits from what you have been doing so far to healthier alternatives. But with such a wide variety of information out there on various diet plans, it can be difficult to understand what to do and not to do while dieting. Here are a few things to keep in mind while dieting:

  • Dont go extreme on your diet
  • Even though it is tempting to cut out the entire junk food list from your meals, it is not recommended. Sudden abstinence from something that we eat on a regular basis will take a toll on our bodies.

  • Take it slow
  • A gradual adjustment to your diet gives your body time to adjust to these changes in the coming days and weeks. Also, this will allow you to monitor how your body reacts to the changes instead of having an unplanned break in your diet routine.

  • Do not go on crash or a harsh diet
  • How To Pick A Successful Weight

    While this study debunked the idea that one diet is superior to the other, or that genetic factors might influence your ability to succeed, it did show that both diet types can be successful if youre willing to adopt the many healthy eating choices the participants were encouraged to take.

    But it also showed that improving your relationship with food and choosing healthy, whole foods may actually be a smarter route than restricting or depriving yourself of specific nutrients.

    In fact, Gardner said one of the benefits many study participants reported to him and his team was that the year of guided eating and nutrition classes helped them improve their relationship with food, and that now they were more thoughtful about how they ate.

    For most people, even a certain plan that might be more one way or more the other usually is not sustainable, Susan Weiner, a registered dietitian and nutritionist and certified diabetes educator for more than 25 years, told Healthline. When we talk about sustainability for the long term, something restrictive does not work. When we overly restrict like a very low-carb or very low-fat diet, it tends to make your body dulled to cues. We stop listening to ourselves because we follow a do and dont list. When you follow a do and dont list for too long, you dont listen to the cues of when youre satisfied. You dont feel the flavors of what youre eating.

    Researchers just dont have those answers yet.

    How To Explain The Results

    The researchers suggested that a key to the results may have been when, after the initial two months, they gave all the participants specific goals for their dietary behaviors, not specific daily caloric limits. Rather than saying “eat this much of that,” they had them personally determine the lowest level of either fats or carbs they needed to not feel hungry, and crucially, to prioritize healthy, nutrient-rich foods when they did it.

    The takeaway for you? Calories may still matterâalthough counting them exactly may not. Protein still matters. Food quality matters. But carbs and fats? Perhaps not so much. Many people find they simply prefer more of one or the otherâi.e., they crave more carbs or more fat. As long as you have those first three priorities lined up, feel free to design your personal diet based on your preferences, and what you can sustain for the long haul.

    Recommended Reading: What Is The Recommended Daily Calorie Intake

    S And Literature Search

    The current meta-analysis is reported in accordance with the Preferred Reporting Items for Systematic Reviews and Meta-Analyses Statement. The protocol for the meta-analysis has been published with the registration number CRD42015020458 in the PROSPERO database and can be accessed at .

    We searched databases such as MEDLINE via Ovid, EMBASE and Cochrane Library in Trials for relevant RCT, with the last search date being 28 May 2015. In addition, references from the retrieved publications were thoroughly reviewed for potentially relevant citations not detected by the electronic search. The search terms were related to both groups of intervention and primary and secondary outcomes . Searches were restricted to RCT performed on humans, which were published in English. No restrictions were imposed on publication dates. The complete search strategy is available in the protocol published with the aforementioned registration number.

    Picking The Best Diet For You


    The researchers also enrolled study participants in two pre-study activities: genome sequencing and a baseline insulin test.

    These genetic and metabolic markers were previously identified as potential factors in determining how well a person might respond to a diet that greatly reduced specific nutrients, such as fat or carbohydrates.

    About 30 percent of people in the test groups had genetic markers that the researchers believed indicated theyd have more success on a low-fat diet.

    About 40 percent showed a low-carb genetic profile.

    However, the profiles and markers did not correspond with any of the weight-loss results. They also didnt help determine any participants weight-loss success.

    Still, Gardner plans to mine the wealth of data he and his team collected and continue to analyze possible markers that can explain a persons weight-loss opportunities.

    Im hoping that we can come up with signatures of sorts, he said. I feel like we owe it to Americans to be smarter than to just say eat less. I still think there is an opportunity to discover some personalization to it now we just need to work on tying the pieces together.

    Also Check: How Many Carbs In Pretzels

    Different People Can Have Different Results On The Same Diet

    Although most diet trials of any kind result in relatively modest average weight loss, there are big variations in how well different people fare on exactly the same diet.

    Within any single test group, the results can vary hugely, with some people losing around 25 kilos and others putting on around 5 regardless of the diet theyâre on.

    To find out why, Christopher Gardner and his team at Stanford University ran a painstakingly detailed clinical trial known as DIETFITS , aiming to understand more about these personal differences and see whether there might be a way of matching the right person to the right diet.

    Fascinating Now Lets Take A Look At How They Did It

    • Both groups cut ~500 calories per day from their diet. They started at ~2000 calories per day and dropped to ~1,500 calories per day.
    • Low-carb group: Cut carbs by ~50% and did not increase fat intake.
    • Low-fat group: Cut total fat by 35% and saturated fat by 43%. They also cut healthy omega-3s by 36%.

    Also Check: How To Cut Out Carbs

    How Did The Researchers Interpret The Results

    The researchers say that, “Calorie for calorie, restriction of dietary fat led to greater body fat loss than restriction of dietary carbohydrate in adults with obesity. This occurred despite the fact that only the carbohydrate-restricted diet led to decreased insulin secretion and a substantial sustained increase in net fat oxidation compared to the baseline energy-balanced diet.”

    They added: “We can definitively reject the claim that carbohydrate restriction is required for body fat loss”, saying that, “Fat loss is a more important goal than weight loss in the treatment of obesity” and that outside of the highly controlled diet lab “diet adherence is likely the most important determinant of body fat loss”.

    What To Eat In A Low Carb Diet

    Stanford’s Christopher Gardner Tackles the Low-Carb vs. Low-Fat Question

    No surprise here, but on a low-carbohydrate diet, you dont eat many starchy grain products like pasta, bread, and other bakery products. Those who are not so strict sometimes eat whole grains. Sweets and sugars, including some fruit sugars, can be pretty much off-limits, too. That means you eat them either less frequently or in smaller quantities. Instead, you draw on protein and fat-rich foods such as meat, fish, eggs, and cheese. Theyll also eat low-sugar fruits, non-starchy vegetables, salad, and nuts in all variations.

    Many swear by limiting carbs as a way to lose weight and keep it off. The lack of carbohydrates forces the body to fall back on its fat reserves. Recent studies have also shown that low-carb could be a healthier diet for us humans. If you exchange carbohydrates for good fats such as olive oil and nuts, you can reduce your heart disease and stroke risk by up to 30 percent. You should also rely on your low-carb meals for good sources of protein. The high protein and fat content ensures fast and long satiation and protects the muscle mass. This is important for long-term weight loss, as your muscles can burn a lot of excess energy.

    Recommended Reading: Calories In Shot Of Bourbon

    /6effective For Short Term

    Both diets are effective in the short term. When you begin with the process of dieting, you cut on calories either by avoiding carbs or fat. In all, the calories consumption decreases which lead to a calorie deficit and hence weight loss. A low carb diet will however help you better because carbs hold onto water weight.

    How The Keto Diet For Beginners Works

    The keto diet is a so-called low-carb healthy-fat or low-carb high-fat diet.

    Accordingly, it reduces carbohydrates and maximizes healthy fats while keeping protein consumption moderate.

    However, few people are aware that this composition lowers insulin, setting the hormonal course in the body to lose weight.

    On the other hand, when you feed your body carbohydrates, it converts them into glucose. Consequently, blood sugar and the level of the storage hormone insulin rise.

    As the name suggests, insulin has the task of storing excess glucose in the form of glycogen and fat.

    As long as stored carbohydrates are present, the body uses them preferentially for energy production.

    When glycogen stores are empty, the body must break down stored fat and convert it into ketones.

    As soon as these fat energy bodies predominantly feed the energy supply, the metabolic state of ketosis is reached.

    In contrast, insulin blocks the enzyme that breaks down body fat .

    In light of this, researchers can now predict up to 75% of gains and losses in overweight individuals based on insulin levels .

    However, it is not only carbohydrates that increase insulin levels.

    Read Also: How Many Carbs Are In Vegetables

    Health Benefits Of A Carbohydrate

    The publication of the PURE study sent a jolt through the nourishing professional world. Even though many assumed that fats make us fat and increase the emergence of cardiovascular illnesses, there is no such connection, according to the PURE study. Surprisingly, high fat intake was instead associated with low mortality. Moreover, the risk of death increased significantly with the number of carbohydrates consumed.

    The ketogenic diet also plays a role in managing epilepsy symptoms. But like all other diets, the ketogenic diet requires discipline and stamina. Once people returned to old eating habits, the weight they lost returned. Many people find it difficult to change long-standing habits so drastically.

    Whats The Difference Between Keto And Low

    Low Carb vs Low Fat: Which Is Best?  Ditch The Carbs

    Since it has already been developed back in the 1960s, the Atkins diet is considered the classic low-carb diet.

    Low-carb diets focus on one thing: reducing carbohydrates.

    But thats where their problem lies. Standard low-carb diets neglect the role of fats and proteins. Because of the ubiquitous demonization of fats, low-carb diets have usually been paired with lean proteins.

    Moreover, until the 1990s, it was unknown that protein can stimulate insulin .

    On the other hand, pure fats such as extra virgin olive oil cause almost no insulin response.

    For this reason, classic low-carb diets such as the Atkins diet are not nearly as effective for weight loss as the keto diet.

    In addition, research has also led health authorities to admit that saturated fat prevents heart disease instead of causing it .

    The ketogenic diet takes advantage of all these new findings.

    Recommended Reading: How Many Carbs Are In Guacamole

    Which Is Better For You It Depends

    Heres a fascinating and insightful quote from the authors of the A TO Z weight-loss study mentioned above: Clinical trials comparing a spectrum of low- to high-carbohydrate diets demonstrate clinically meaningful weight loss on any reduced-calorie diet regardless of macronutrient composition, provided there is adequate adherence to the dietary regimen.21 Hey, thats what I just said!

    In other words, both reduced-calorie low-fat and low-carb diets can work. The one that is going to work best for you is the one that you can stick to. I know thats not earth-shattering. But it is important. And more important than the debate of low-carb vs low-fat.

    While we typically look at psychological, emotional, behavioral, and environmental factors that can influence compliance, these authors set out to identify whether there were any physiological variables that might affect dietary adherence by influencing factors like hunger and metabolism. Interestingly, they found insulin resistant participants were less likely to stick to and lose weight on a low-fat diet compared to insulin-sensitive folks assigned to the same diet.

    In other words, IR folks may do comparatively better on a low-carb diet. In the A TO Z study, for instance, IR folks lost nearly 3 TIMES more weight on the low-carb diet than on the low-fat diet.21,22 This isnt the first time an observation of this nature has been noticed. And it suggests we may be able to personalize nutrition based on physiological variables.23

    Other Effects On Health

    Low fat and low carb diets may affect other aspects of health in different ways. These include:

    • Cholesterol. A review of eight studies found low carb diets to be more effective at improving levels of HDL cholesterol and decreasing triglyceride levels than low fat diets. Neither diet significantly affected LDL cholesterol (
    • ).


    Getting Started With A Low

    Fats are important for maintaining good health and fitness. Essential fatty acids is fat that our body cannot produce and relies on sources outside. Therefore, it is important that as you bring your daily fat intake below 20% of your portion, at no point should you deprive your body of these fatty acids.

    Reducing the portion of fat in your diet will demand limiting the use of oil, ghee, butter, or any other visible fat to less than two teaspoons per day. This will also mean avoiding processed foods that are often high in trans fats, which increase cholesterol that gets deposited in the inner linings of the arteries.

    There are invisible sources of fats that make up your diets like nuts, and dairy like milk, cottage cheese, etc. These invisible fats need to be curbed to follow a low-fat diet.

    While sources of fat like salmon, mackerel, etc. are good sources of omega-3 fat and can provide essential fatty acids, for someone who is a vegetarian, these needs should be fulfilled by eating a mix of green leafy vegetables and seeds. Your low-fat diet should not only help you lose weight, but also provide the benefits fat has to offer.

    Our Expert Gives You The Real Scoop On Which Diet Will Get You Leaner

    Low Carb vs Low Fat Diets – Which is Better for Fat Loss?

    What happens when you run a year-long trial pitting low-carb diets versus low-fat diets? The media erupts, of course. In the case of a recent study coming out of Johns Hopkins and Tulane Universities, which showed that low-carb diets performed better in just about every possible metric, the media frenzy was almost palpable.

    But did the study actually show what headlines conveyed? Headlines normally dont tell the full story, even on our website, so its important to look at what these trials are actually telling usand that, at times, involves hours of reading and research. Most of us dont have the time to do that, but luckily there are experts who can break down the facts for us. And thats exactly what weve done here.

    Kamal Patel is the cofounder of Examine.com, one of the Internets largest resources of nutrition research. Hes been writing about nutrition for more than 20 years, so he knows more about the subject than the Instagram influencers giving their hot take on this study or the journalists taking a stab at dissecting it.

    This article takes all the jargon out of the research paper and presents it in a way that anyone can understandthis way, youll be armed with the facts the next time your gym bro or uncle tries to tell you something thats not blatantly true.

    Low-carb and low-fat diets are some of the trendiest eating regimens, and so its important to understand whats real and whats not about them.

    Question: What Conclusions Can You Draw From This Low Carb Vs Low Fat Study

    Answer: To me, it shows that both methods have benefits, but the reduction in carbs isnt that much better as some dieters believe. At Vida180, a diet must fit into your everyday life so that it can be maintained in the long term.

    I still advocate changing your diet to really get leaner and healthier. I also consider the reduction of body fat mass to be the most important goal, because this can bring clear advantages. It can help prevent nutrition-related diseases and the risk of type 2 diabetes, and also help you to stay slimmer in the long term.

    My final conclusion on low carb vs. low fat is therefore: Pay attention to both carbohydrates and fat intake.

    In plain language: Avoid sugar and white flour in your diet, and reduce the portion size of carbohydrate-containing dishes. Reduce hidden fat that comes from ready-made meals and baked goods. Consciously integrate healthy sources of fat such as high-quality oils, fatty fish and nuts into your diet plan.

    Crash or highly-restrictive diets dont work. Anything that cant be sustained in your diet is likely to fail in the long-term.

    Instead, pick the best parts of both the low-carb and the low-fat diets. Making positive changes in your eating habits and lifestyle give you the best chance of being able to reduce your weight and keep it off.

    Latest Recipes

    More Recipes Like This