Are Beans Protein Or Carb

Must Try

They Are High In Fibre

Are Beans High in Carbs? Diabetic Diet Essentials! SugarMD

Beans are a great source of fibre, and that’s one of the reasons I’m so excited to share this post with you!

Fibre is important for your body because it helps improve your digestive system. It also helps prevent constipation, maintain regular bowel movements, and lower blood cholesterol.

Beans have more fibre than most other foods, which is why they’re such a great choice for those who want to eat healthier.

What Macronutrients Do Beans Contain

If youd like to understand more about how beans can be categorised as either a protein, a carbohydrate, or a vegetable, lets look more closely at the nutrients beans contain.

This table shows the nutritional content of one of the most popular types of beans, the red kidney bean. Different types of beans will have slightly differing amounts of nutrients, particularly micronutrients , but this data gives a general guide. And since a quantity is meaningless unless you know how many grams were supposed to be eating each day, Ive also included the percentage of the RDA for each nutrient.


As you can see, beans are a fantastic source of both the macronutrients protein and carbohydrate, as well as fibre, which is also hugely important for our bodies . You could quite reasonably consider beans and other legumes to be part of both the protein and carbohydrate food groups.

Counting On A Diabetes Diet

The U.S. Department of Agriculture recommends counting beans as a protein if you haven’t already met your recommended protein servings with other foods and counting any remaining servings of beans you eat as part of your vegetable servings.

If you are diabetic and counting carbohydrates, however, you’ll need to count the carbohydrates in the beans and include them in your total carbohydrates for the meal even if you are using beans as your protein source for the meal. When carbohydrate counting, you can subtract the grams of fiber from the total carbohydrates to get net carbohydrates if a serving of the food contains more than 5 grams. This will bring the carbohydrates in many types of beans down to about one 15-gram serving.

Read Also: How Many Calories Should I Intake To Lose Weight

Slow Carb Refried Beans Using Instantpot

Refried beans are often made with dried pinto beans and making them from scratch in an instantpot is leaps and bounds tastier than from a can. Most beans are compliant with a slow carb diet and ithey offer a great protein source as a side to many Mexican dishes. Refried beans are also a tasty, but nutritious dip for chips if you are not counting carbs.

Find Out Exactly Where Beans Fit Into Our Diet

Are beans too high carb to be considered a protein source? Which ...

Certain foods can be confusing when it comes to figuring out where to fit them in the diet. For example, potatoes are technically a vegetable, but because they provide about 15 grams of carbohydrate per serving, they actually are considered a carbohydrate.

Beans are a similar story. While beans, peas, and lentils are vegetables, theyre considered starchy vegetables because of their carbohydrate content and health experts recommend treating them as a carbohydrate exchange. On a plant-based diet, beans can contribute significantly towards your daily protein needs. However, you still want to be mindful to keep them within the context of a meal that provides some healthy fat and does not contain excessive amounts of carbs from a lot of additional grains or starchy vegetables.

Hummus is also considered a carbohydrate source because its made from beans and provides some protein, but you would need to eat a lot of it to meet your needs. A 2-tablespoon serving provides around 75 calories and offers about 2 grams of each fiber and protein.

That said, beans are a great carb choice. In addition, because of their high protein and fiber content, they break down slowly so you stay full for longer and experience more stable blood sugar and energy than you would if you ate a similar amount of simple carbs, like white bread or a pastry.

Here are a few delicious, well-balanced ways to incorporate beans into your diet:

Recommended Reading: Low Carb Cheese Cake Recipe

Are Beans Good Carbs

Whether kidney, lima, pinto or black, beans deserve a place in your healthy diet. They’re naturally low in fat, high in fiber, rich in antioxidants and dense in minerals such as iron, zinc, calcium and selenium as well as the B vitamin folate. Beans contain good carbohydrates, and if you’re like most Americans, you can use healthier carbohydrates in your diet. Many Americans consume a diet high in highly refined or processed carbs.

Video of the Day

Are Carbs Bad For You

In the nutrition world, the claim that eating carbs make you fat is one of the biggest misconceptions around. Fruits, vegetables, whole grains, beans, and legumes all fall into the carb category, along with soda, desserts, chips, pretzels, and other processed foods. Distinguishing the healthy from the not-so-healthy carbs is one of the keys to figuring out how to eat right on a plant-based diet. Whereas whole food carbs provide beneficial vitamins, minerals, fiber, and antioxidants to the diet, processed refined carbs often lack nutrients, which get stripped out in processing. Its well known that eating an ultra-processed diet is associated with an increased risk of obesity and heart disease, making choosing the right type of carbs key to a healthy diet.

The Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend that 45 to 65 percent of your total daily calories come from carbohydrates. In other words, the majority of your diet should consist of carbs. This translates to about 3 to 5 grams per kilogram of body weight per day. For a 150-pound individual, thats about 195 to 330 grams of carbs each day.

The number of daily carbs a person needs varies greatly based on activity level, with active people needing more. Since carbs are the primary fuel for exercise, those who engage in regular endurance activity may need anywhere from 5 to 10 grams of carbs per kilogram of body weight per day. For that same 150-pound person, that equals 330 to 675 grams of carbs each day.

Recommended Reading: How Many Calories Is Granola

The Expert: Dr Guy Crosby

Legumes, which include beans, peas and lentils, are an inexpensive, healthy source of protein, potassium, and complex carbohydrates, including dietary fiber.

  • On average, legumes contain about 20-25% protein by weight on a dry basis, which is 2-3 times more protein than wheat and rice. However, they tend to be low in the essential amino acid methionine, and sometimes tryptophan.
  • Legumes are also a very good source of dietary fiber, which is important for maintaining healthy bowel function.
  • The content of total carbohydrate, including complex carbohydrates, ranges from 65-72% by weight on a dry basis, of which 85% is composed of starch, while dietary fiber constitutes anywhere from 10-20% of the weight of dried legumes .

The high level of both starch and dietary fiber raises a very interesting question. If most of the carbohydrate is made of starch, how can legumes be such good sources of dietary fiber? Isnt all starch rapidly digested to glucose? This was the prevailing view of starch until the 1980s, when two English researchers, Hans Englyst and John Cummings discovered that not all starch is rapidly digested to glucose in the small intestine .

There are two main forms of dietary fiber in food:

  • One is insoluble fiber comprised of complex carbohydrates, such as cellulose, that are insoluble in the gastrointestinal fluid. This form of fiber is not broken down by gut bacteria, acts as a bulking agent, and is effective at reducing constipation.
  • Food

    Protein And Carbohydrate Content In Foods

    Rice, beans, and the “myth” of protein combining

    How much protein is really in peanut butter? Which foods have the most carbs? Nutrition Divas answers may surprise you.

    Lizette writes, Can you explain what types of foods contain protein, carbohydrates, and starches so that we know exactly what you mean when you use these terms?

    I like to think that its possible to eat healthy without having a degree in nutrition. So when I talk about nutrients like protein or carbohydrates, I always try to include examples of actual foods. For example, in my article on the benefits of protein, I suggested that protein foods such as eggs, meat, fish, soy, peanuts, and other legumes are great for controlling your appetite because they keep you satisfied for longer. Ive also talked about out the importance of portion control when eating starches such as bread, pasta, rice, and other grains.

    But the truth is that none of those protein foods are pure protein and none of the starches are pure carbohydrates. Although I dont want to make things more complicated than they need to be, perhaps its time for quick review of which nutrients these basic foods provide.

    You May Like: Low Carb Low Sugar Bread

    Master List Of Common Beans And Their Carb Counts

    Here’s a list of common beans like pinto, black, and kidney, and their net carb counts. This chart is entirely based on 1 cup of beans since that is a decent serving amount!

    24.2g 2.8g

    As you can see, apart from black soybeans and green beans, most bean varieties are super high in carbs, and that doesn’t make them very friendly to ketoers.

    Net Carbs Of Beans Compared To Other Foods

    Below is a chart comparing a range of foods and their total carbs, fiber, and net carbs, along with what % DV of total carbs the food provides.

    You may also wonder what the definition of a low-carb food is. The FDA says that 5% of the DV or less of any nutrient can be considered low in that nutrient2. The total carbs in 100 grams of black beans are 6% of the DV, very close to the 5% definition of low carb. Their net carbs are 3.5% of carb DV, so by that measure, black beans are well within the definition of low carb. .

    A few interesting facts are revealed in the table immediately below:

    • Black beans have about half the net carbs of white potatoes.
    • Black beans are higher in total carbs than a Granny Smith apple, but lower in net carbs.
    • Black beans have more fiber per serving than any other food on this list, including whole what bread.

    You May Like: Lowest Carb Beans For Chili

    What Are The Health Benefits Of A Plant

    “Beans and legumes are the often unsung heroes of the plant-based world,” says Katherine Brooking, MS, RD, a registered dietitian in San Francisco, and the co-founder of the nutrition news company Appetite for Health. “They are rich in protein and high in minerals and fiber, without the saturated fat found in some animal proteins. A diet that includes beans and legumes may also help improve your blood cholesterol, a leading cause of heart disease, and improve digestion, research has proven.”

    And that dream team of fiber and protein help keep you full longer, making it easier to lose weight or maintain weight loss.

    “Including just a half-cup to full cup of legumes daily is all you need to reach these benefits,” says Samantha Previte, RD, a registered dietitian with Dietitians of Palm Valley in Ponte Vedra Beach, Florida.

    What Are Pinto Beans

    Beans are high in protein, complex carbohydrates, folate and iron. They ...

    Pinto beans are tan-colored, oval-shaped beans with specks of reddish-brown. Metaphorically, each pinto bean resembles a painting, and in Spanish “pinto” means painted. Pinto beans are a staple in Mexican and Southwestern American cuisine. The beans are soft, creamy, nutty and earthy, making them perfect for burritos, fajitas, tacos, quesadillas.

    You can find pinto beans in grocery stores as dried beans or canned beans. They are affordable, easy to prepare and nutritious. This cholesterol- and gluten-free plant-based protein is vegetarian- and vegan-friendly, making it a commonly used ingredient in many savory and sweet dishes.

    You May Like: How Many Carbs In Cauliflower Rice

    May Promote Heart Health

    Adding black beans to your diet may help lower blood cholesterol and high blood pressure levels.

    For example, saponin compounds in black beans act as antioxidants with cholesterol-lowering capacities. The beans fiber may also help reduce total cholesterol and triglyceride levels .

    In fact, studies show that for every 10 grams of total fiber consumed, the risk of mortality from heart disease may decrease by 27%. Similarly, consuming 510 grams of soluble fiber per day may reduce LDL cholesterol levels by 5% (

    10 ).

    However, another study found that consuming 1/2 cup of beans daily had no significant effect on cholesterol levels. So, it is possible that heart health benefits may only be seen if you eat more than this serving size of beans daily .

    Research has also found an inverse correlation between bean fiber intake and blood pressure, specifically that higher fiber intakes result in lower readings .

    In addition, flavonoids in black beans may help prevent platelet aggregation and encourage muscle relaxation, which further contributes to the blood-pressure-lowering effect .

    Similarly, another study determined that consuming 3/4 cup of black beans had a vasorelaxant effect, meaning that it helped relax the muscles within blood vessels to lower blood pressure (

    Is It Ok To Eat Beans Everyday

    Additionally, eating beans every day can benefit your heart in other ways as well because of the high amount of fiber in them, according to Ivanir. The fiber keeps you fuller for longer, she continued. So it can decrease your calorie load and cause weight loss which indirectly helps heart health.

    You May Like: How Much Carbs In Apple

    Are Canned Beans Healthy Nutrition Benefits And Downsides

    Beans are members of the legume family plants that produce pods with seeds inside.

    Theyre a staple food in some cultures and an important source of plant-based protein and other essential nutrients, such as iron and folate .

    People in the United States commonly consume black beans, pinto beans, and navy beans, among other types. You can buy them either dried or canned.

    When we refer to canned beans in this article, were talking about cooked beans in a can with no flavoring, not baked beans or other prepared beans in a can.

    People dont typically recognize canned beans for their health benefits. Some might think theyre nutritionally inferior or harmful compared with dried beans. You may wonder if theyre unhealthy for you, particularly if you have high blood pressure (

    Where Do Beans Fit In The Food Pyramid / Myplate

    How Much Carbs are there in Beans? : Are Beans Keto Friendly?

    If you grew up in the 1990s or early noughties, youll probably remember the food pyramid. We were all taught to eat large quantities of grains and cereals, plenty of fruits and vegetables, and then smaller amounts of animal products , and to eat particularly fatty foods sparingly. When displayed as a graphic, this recommendation made a very satisfying pyramid.

    However, Ive only recently found out that the food pyramid was actually updated in 2005, and in 2011 it was done away with altogether .

    These days, the USDA advises that we follow the MyPlate guide, which gives us an idea of how much of our diet should be comprised of fruits, vegetables, grains, protein, and dairy.

    The UK government offer a similar circular guide, known as the Eatwell guide, which shows the various food groups as proportions of our overall diets.

    The UKs Eatwell guide includes beans and other legumes under the protein umbrella. The USAs MyPlate guide includes pulses under both the vegetable and protein categories, recognising the unique nutrient composition of these foods.

    If you need a little help making sure youre eating the right balance, these divided plates on Amazon are designed around the official MyPlate guidance from the USDA:

    You May Like: Free Printable Low Carb Food List

    Beans: Carbohydrate Protein Or A Musical Fruit

    Beans, beans, the musical fruit. Youve probably heard the silly rhyme. As it turns out, beans are not a fruit or a vegetable. They are legumes, or seeds, from a family of plants that produces seedpods. Legumes include beans, lentils, some types of peas, and peanuts. When we refer to beans in the legume family, were talking about all types of beans except the vegetable green bean.

    Whats so great about beans? They are cheap and healthy. Many people have tight food budgets in this challenging economy. Beans are inexpensive, shelf-stable, and full of nutrients. With research studies supporting a plant-based diet for healthy diabetes management, beans are a great addition to your meal routine.

    Bean Nutrients

    While the nutrition facts vary a bit among types of beans, all beans are packed full of nutrients. For example, ½ cup of black beans contains 8 grams of protein, 6 grams of fiber, significant amounts of iron and potassium, and only 1 gram of fat. It also contains 21 grams of carbohydrate. Thats right beans contain both carbohydrate and protein.

    Beans and Diabetes

    You still need to account for the carbohydrate in beans if you take insulin or are on a carbohydrate-counting plan. If you use the plate method for diabetes, the beans take up space in both the carbohydrate and protein sections.

    Cooking Beans

    Beans and Gas

    Getting Started with Beans

    What Type Of Carbs Are In Beans

    The carbohydrate content of beans consists mainly of starch and dietary fiber. Beans contain negligible amounts of sugars.

    Most noteworthy, beans are the best dietary sources of fiber. Actually, the 25-40% of carbs in beans are fiber. The rest is starch.

    Following a diet high in fiber is good for you. High fiber intakes may lower the risk of developing coronary heart disease, stroke, hypertension, diabetes, obesity, and certain gastrointestinal diseases.

    Sharp increase in fiber intake may cause discomfort and a series of side effects, though. So, you better increase the consumption of beans gradually.

    You May Like: Calories In Plain Greek Yogurt

    Latest Recipes

    More Recipes Like This